Tulsa Man Sentenced to 50 Years in Federal Prison in Cold Case Killing

Jamalo Bruner Jr.
Jamalo Bruner Jr.

TULSA, Oklahoma - A federal judge sentenced a Tulsa man to 50 years in prison for his role in a 2019 armed robbery that ended with the shooting death of 22-year-old Benjamin Montgomery. U.S. District Judge Gregory K. Frizzell also ordered five years of supervised release for Jamalo Bruner Jr.

Bruner earlier pleaded guilty to using a firearm during and in relation to a crime of violence that resulted in a death.

Robbery went wrong at Tulsa apartment complex

According to court records, Bruner and another armed participant planned on October 10, 2019, to rob Aaron Pritchard of marijuana. Both carried 9mm pistols and waited for Pritchard at the Bellevue Apartments in Tulsa. They confronted him at gunpoint.

The pair struck Pritchard in the head with a pistol and ordered him to take them to an apartment. Pritchard could not find a key to the apartment they wanted, so he went to a neighboring unit where Montgomery lived.

Bruner and his accomplice forced their way inside while still holding Pritchard at gunpoint. A shot went through the front door and into the ceiling as they entered. Montgomery was in the apartment with five friends.

Montgomery confronted the gunmen to protect the people inside. During the struggle, someone shot him in the chest, and he died. Bruner and the other man ran from the scene.

Investigators could not determine which of the two fired the fatal shot. The evidence, however, established Bruner's active role in the armed robbery and the firearm offense that led to Montgomery's death.

New leads reopened the case

The homicide stayed unsolved for several years. FBI investigators and the Tulsa Police Department Homicide Unit developed new leads and reopened the case. DNA testing produced a profile consistent with Bruner's DNA, which helped investigators tie him to the crime.

The case joins other Oklahoma cold case homicides that have reached the courts after years of investigation.

Family remembers a protector

Montgomery's family members and friends spoke at sentencing about the lasting effect of his death and the years of grief that followed. They said they were grateful to law enforcement and prosecutors and believed justice had been served.

Montgomery had turned 22 just three days before he died. Family described him as a loyal son, devoted brother, trusted friend, athlete and animal lover who looked out for others. His mother said he regularly showed compassion to strangers and stayed exceptionally close to his family. Loved ones said he instinctively stood up for others, and that his final actions reflected the courage and selflessness that defined his life.

"Jamalo Bruner helped orchestrate a violent armed robbery and set in motion the chain of events that took Benjamin Montgomery's life," said U.S. Attorney Christopher J. Nassar. "The 50-year federal sentence is a just and significant punishment for a senseless crime that devastated a family and shocked our community. Benjamin was only 22 years old. His loved ones described a young man known for his compassion and willingness to protect others. On the night he was killed, he did exactly that, confronting armed intruders in an effort to protect his friends. While no sentence can restore Benjamin's stolen future or erase the pain his family has carried for years, today's outcome delivers meaningful justice."

FBI Oklahoma City Special Agent in Charge Doug Goodwater also commented on the sentence.

"The defendant's actions resulted in the tragic death of a young man and forever changed the lives of his family and loved ones. This sentence reflects the serious consequences of those actions," Goodwater said. "The FBI remains committed to pursuing justice on behalf of all victims of violence, and the families who bear the impact of these senseless crimes."

Assistant U.S. Attorney Tyson McCoy prosecuted the case. The FBI and the Tulsa Police Department Homicide Unit investigated it.

The U.S. Attorney's Office singled out Tulsa Police Detective Lacy Lansdown, who led the investigation that solved the case. It also credited Homicide Unit Case Support Specialist Margot Heyne-Bell for her assistance.

For more local reports, see Crime news.