Broken Arrow Police Chief Lance Arnold Remains on Paid Leave During Investigation

Lance Arnold
Lance Arnold

BROKEN ARROW, Oklahoma - The City of Broken Arrow says an outside investigator is still reviewing the operations and management of its police department, and Police Chief Lance Arnold remains on paid administrative leave while that work continues. The city released an update on the Broken Arrow police chief's leave on Monday.

City leaders announced the leave on October 14. They have not shared details of the inquiry, saying they want to protect Arnold's rights as an employee and the integrity of the investigation.

Why the city opened the investigation

City Manager Michael Spurgeon told news media on October 14 that the investigation was necessary because of multiple matters the city's Legal Department brought to him in late September. Those matters concerned the operations and management of the police department, according to the city.

Arnold has been told why he was placed on leave. An independent investigator from outside the Tulsa metro area is handling the inquiry. The city said the goal is a fair and thorough investigation that weighs the facts, applicable law, departmental policies and leadership responsibilities.

Who decides what happens next

The city's update spent considerable space on how Broken Arrow's government works. The city operates under a council-manager form of government. The City Council adopts legislation, sets policy and hires the city manager. The city manager carries out those policies and oversees daily operations.

The city manager supervises two assistant city managers and 17 department directors, including the police chief.

The city cited two sections of Oklahoma law. Under Title 11, Section 106, the council can inquire into the conduct and investigation of municipal affairs. Under Title 11, Section 10-107, the council may not ask the city manager or another authority to appoint or remove employees.

The city said that under state law, the decision on next steps after the investigation ends rests solely with the city manager.

City asks for patience

The city acknowledged that the lack of details may frustrate some residents. It said the decision to open an internal investigation "was not taken lightly" and that the process must follow organizational policies that protect an employee's rights and limit liability to the city.

The city said it will provide another update when the investigation ends. It did not give a timeline.

Acting Police Chief Scott Bennett is leading the department in the meantime. The city said the City Council and administration fully support all Broken Arrow Police Department employees, and that the commitment to residents' safety continues.

For more coverage, see local news from across Oklahoma.